My Store: Store Details (change)

My Shopping List

Your shopping list is empty!

It's easy to use -- just click on anything that says "Add to List" or enter your own items today!

Spooky Eyeball Pudding

Active Time: 20 Minutes

Total Time: 20 Minutes

Serves: 4


Spooky Eyeball Pudding


  • Twist apart 4 cookies; reserve plain halves. Decorate cream halves with red and black gel to resemble an eyeball; set aside. Crush remaining 8 cookies and 4 plain halves; set aside.
  • Stir together chocolate pudding and peanut butter in small bowl; Stir together vanilla pudding and food coloring in another small bowl.
  • Layer half of crushed cookies, chocolate pudding, remaining half of crushed cookies and vanilla pudding in 4 small serving dishes or plastic cups. Top each with sprinkles and a decorated cookie.


Serving Size: 4 servings (1 dessert each)
  • Calories 333kcal -
  • Total Fat 15g -
  • Saturated Fat 5g -
  • Cholesterol 0mg -
  • Sodium 321mg -
  • Carbohydrates 47g -
  • Fiber 3g -
  • Protein 5g -